White House Calls
|
|
Literally within days of making his transition out
of office in January after having served an unprecedented
six terms as Governor of Vermont, Howard Dean was on
the road making appearances as the first announced candidate
seeking the Democratic nomination for the 2004 Presidential
elections. The plain-spoken physician took time during
a campaign stop in Atlanta to talk with A&Us
B. Andrew Plant about healthcare policy, AIDS, and the
limits of the Bush Administration.
|
It is sometimes difficult to get a potential interviewee
to commit. More accurately, it usually takes some tenacity
to navigate the egos and protocol of the people who keep the
schedules of the people we need and want to hear from on the
subject of AIDS. And scheduling an interview with former Vermont
Governor Howard Dean was no easier than scheduling other interviewsbut
for different reasons.
Simply put, with Dean having just handed over his job as
Governor to his successor the previous week, he and his advisors
were busy putting the basics of a campaign for President in
place. Dean for America had to create itself almost over night,
setting up offices, getting computers up and running, adding
more to the workloads of what is from any perspective a lean
campaign team, hiring additional staff, organizing volunteers,
and, yes, juggling requests for interviews and "photo
opportunities" from pesky writers like me.
The key difference of these scheduling difficulties, however,
is that there seems to be no real ego attached. Of course
Dean wanted to do the interview; he is the "dark horse"
candidate among a field of better-known, if-not-announced,
contenders, who has the most to gain from exposure in the
media. The lack of self-importance on the part of Dean that
I observed while setting up the logistics of an interview
exemplify the man the public is getting to know during these
early days of his campaign.
The physician-turned-public servant "calls em
as he sees em," as observed by an audience member
during this Atlanta campaign stop. Indeed, Dean does not mince
words. While he is articulatewell-versed on the issues
and well-aware of the current trend of extreme political correctnesshe
prefers to break through the clutter and communicate clearly
and directly via the power of his shoot-from-the-hip style.
Yes, he wants to be Presidential, but not at the expense of
his ideals.
Those ideals include the larger scope: "I am running
for President because I believe this country is fundamentally
headed in the wrong direction
it is time for change."
Deans narrower "focus issues" are simple,
and perhaps a bit radical, and draw distinctly from his successes
in Vermont. "I am proud that virtually every child under
eighteen and more than ninety percent of adults in Vermont
are eligible for health coverage," he says. "
[A]s
a country, the United States can do better on this front."
Answering questions at the conclusion of his address to the
Atlanta Executive Network in January, Dean raised his voice
over the early clapping of hands and explained more specifically
what he means by our country doing better, and zeroes in very
plainly on who he is criticizing.
"So, when some conservative group asks me about family
values, Im going to say, Where are the family
values that say black people cant get into medical school?
Where are the family values that make sure women have no say
over whether they get pregnant or not? Where are the family
values in changing scientific facts to make sure that teenagers
have no idea how to avoid the contraction of AIDS and other
diseases? If thats what family values are, ladies
and gentlemen, then this country is ready for something different!"
After several such strong declarations, one audience member
urged Dean to "say something that you like about [President]
George Bush." The reply was characteristically straightforwardand
humorous. "When he was in Texas, he was relatively moderate,"
Dean said.
As Dean exited the ballroom this night in Atlanta and the
crowd began to disperse, a woman who mistook my notepad and
tape recorder for the tools of a newspaper reporter leaned
close and conspiratorially offered, "Tell people who
read your newspaper that this guy doesnt talk about
a program without talking about how to pay for it!"
As I wrote down her spontaneous offering, she asked what
I was there to hear him talk about. When I told her, she said,
"HIV and AIDS? From what Ive heard [here tonight]
thats something he would know how to do something about.
He at least mentioned it; the others wont even do that!"
With that, she disappeared back into the crowd. No doubt
Candidate Dean would be pleased that someone in his audience
understood the way he is casting his candidacya balance
of fiscal prudence and social responsibility. "I know
I have been compared to [2000 presidential candidate] John
McCain," Dean told the Atlanta audience, "for my
directness, at least
but I am more progressive [in terms
of social programs]."
And Howard Dean is a straightforward guy, as reflected in
his talk I had heard this evening, and even more so when he
sat down with me later in the evening for one of his first
interviews of Dean for America 2004. Yes, it is tough to get
a high-profile person to take time for an interview, but Dean
understands the importance of doing so. He also realizes that
he is sitting down for an interview about AIDSsomething
other presidential candidates might rather face in a more
circuitous way.
Presidential hopeful and Congressman Richard Gephardt has
talked openly about AIDS. So, did former Vice President Al
Gore, though he has now bowed out of the race. The other candidates
are slow to weigh in on issues at allespecially tough
ones like HIV and AIDS. In fact, when Dean and I spoke, he
was the first announced candidate for the election; he wants
to start the race and be on the record, letting others leave
the public to speculate on their candidacies and stands on
issues. Typical Dean candor.
His candorand his early entry into the 2004 Presidential
Raceare likely to be credited with, as he jokingly told
the Atlanta audience, doubling his position in polling over
the prior two months. Dean laughed at the statistics because
he had moved from a two percent recognition factor to a four
percent recognition factor. He seemed to delight in both the
valid progress and in the absurdity of the smallish numbers.
As a medical doctor, and as a governor who made improved
access to healthcare one of his hallmarks, HIV/AIDS is an
issue that is very much already on Howard Deans radar
screen. "When I was training [in medical school], HIV/AIDS
was not a big issuearound 1978but by the time
I got into practice it was," he says. "As a physician
it is a fascinating disease, but, obviously, a horrible one
for the community."
And it has just gotten worse, Dean notes. "Now teenagers
are the fastest growing group that contracts HIV/AIDS,"
he says. "Straight teenagers are increasingly infected."
He also is quick to say that gay menespecially younger
gay menhave forgotten how terrible AIDS is. "It
is still a very bad disease. One of the things I worry about
and that we need to cope with is the re-education process;
young gay people who are engaging in unprotected sex because
they think retroviral therapy will allow them to live a symptom-free
life. Retroviral therapy is not pleasant. The gay community
needs to focus
many gay men have forgotten how awful
this scourge was when it first began."
Its natural to ask the former leader of the state how
Vermonts healthcare system helped people with AIDS.
"The fact that people have insurance in general is an
enormous help. "Dean says. "As we all know, HIV/AIDS
is a very expensive disease to deal with
."
Specifically, he says there are two aspects of the Vermont
system that are somewhat unique. "First of all, so many
people have insurance, and second of all, [Vermont] has such
a well-developed hospice system," Dean notes. "That
[hospice care] was an especially big deal in the beginning,
because people contracted HIV, went downhill pretty rapidly
and didnt last too long. But now we are saving a lot
more peoplehelping them live better and longer because
of triple therapy and greater understanding about the disease
in general. So the hospice end of things is not as big a focus,
but paying for treatment and prescriptions is more important
than ever."
But the "universal healthcare system" Dean often
speaks of as being modeled on Vermont but applicable nationally
is not what you might imagine. "No one would have to
change their insurance if they dont want to. I dont
want to change the whole system as we know it," he says.
"We showed in 1993 that people wont put up with
that. Rather, we would work within an existing system to insure
as many people as possible.
"Under the system that I propose, everyone would have
access to healthcare, so a question of covering HIV and AIDS
would not be a question," Dean says. "Because people
would have healthcare coverage. Period."
He is quick to add that, "we do expect people to paythey
cant expect healthcare to be free. But with guaranteed
issue, they stand a better chance of having health insurance.
Of course, if you dont have any money, then you are
going to get full public benefits. And we would need to broaden
those."
Under the Vermont system, although insurers must offer guaranteed
issue health insurance and they cannot refuse to cover someone,
they dont have to cover them for the first six months
or something like thata "pre-existing exclusion
period," as it is called by most insurors. (Guaranteed
issue insurance usually involves an insurance application
which asks few or no health questions; or, in the case of
Vermont, insurers may ask what they like, but they cannot
refuse coverage based on the answers.)
"You dont want people taking advantage of it
moving
in from out of state or such
," Dean says, so you
keep safeguards in place, but you do get everyone insured
eventually.
Regarding this universal coverage and our social obligation
to put such in place, he is fond of saying that, "[w]e
ought not to be the last industrialized country in the world
to guarantee health insurance to all of our citizens."
Guaranteeing coverage to all Americans would involve a mix
of state and federal programs, Dean says, in addition to existing
private sector programs. States would be required to guarantee
coverage to all children (including all persons under twenty-three,
he says). Federal programs would have responsibility for acute
medical care and prescriptions for anyone over sixty-five.
Employer-based systemsmuch as they exist nowwould
cover everyone else.
How would President Dean pay for this everyman healthcare
coverage? Thats where his mantra of fiscal responsibility
comes into play. Repeal President Bushs tax cuts and
balance the national budget, for a start, Dean told his Atlanta
audiences. "We cannot have the social programs we want
and need without solid financial grounding."
Specifically, he notes that just one quarter of the tax cuts
he wants to see repealed would pay for an expansion of Medicare
that could see a much broader prescription benefit for people
over sixty-five for ten years. Ramping up Medicares
pharmaceutical package in this way would make it "a decent
insurance program," Dean says.
But what about working-age citizens who fall through the
cracks of employer-based systems and governmental benefits
programs? "We would look to things like refundable tax
credits and federal subsidies to cover low- and moderate-income
Americans who lack insurance."
And he definitely casts himself as more progressive than
the current President. "The Bush Administration is really
backsliding on AIDS issues because these people are ideologically
driven, not driven by thoughtfulness," he says. Referring
to ongoing allegations that followers of the current administration
have done things like remove condom information from federal
Web sites, he notes:."[Its] foolish. All it does is increase
the number of people with HIV/AIDS."
He continues, saying that, "it is a very backward approach
in terms of public health. Yes, we need to teach responsibility,
but we have to educate people too
as much information
as we can get and give." Dean reiterates that, "in
Vermont we concentrated most on public health education and
that helps everybody. It is doing things with a long-term
outlook. You not only help people dealing with challenges
like AIDS right now, but you foster children who will be healthy
and who will be good citizens as adults."
Zeroing in just on the AIDS crisis again, but continuing
on one of his favorite themeshealth education, Dean
shares an anecdote about spending a week in Burkina Faso,
the African country where an international AIDS conference
was held just a few years ago.
"The African countries that are really serious in trying
to deal with AIDS are really so far ahead of Americans in
terms of public education," he says. "We really
need to be much more frank in a national discussion about
sexuality because thats how AIDS is principally spread."
"And weve got to stress things like condom use.
It makes me ill to see the [U.S. Presidential] Administration
doing things based on religious sentiments rather than scientific
facts
.Its hurting so many people. It is hurting
so many kids," Dean says, shaking his head. "I am
all for teenage abstinence. But you have to educate kids and
teach them how to protect themselves from unwanted pregnancy
and HIV/AIDS. Its naive to not do that! It is depressing
to me that the Bush Administration is catering to the Religious
Right and sending kids to their death while they are doing
it."
Dean shrugs again and says he knows he is repeating himself
but that he firmly believes some of the answers are that simple.
"I think public health and education are the parts really
being ignored right now in Washington," he says. "Of
course, [we already know that] prevention is far more effective
than treatment. We have a better chance of winning against
AIDS if we can stop the spread. Slow the infection rate. Lessen
the number of people who have it that we have to care for
[medically]."
Dean is fond of saying that frank discussionabout finances,
sexuality, human rights, abstinence, condoms, who influences
whom politically and other subjects"is critical
if we are going to stop the increase in [AIDS] cases."
What call to the people does Presidential-hopeful Dean make
in regards to the AIDS pandemic? "I hate to sound like
a broken record," he says, shrugging a bit, "but
education, education, education. Bring people with HIV/AIDS
into classrooms to talk about it. Do whatever you can to make
people understand AIDS prevention and what we must do for
people who already have it. Public-health education and some
kind of health care coverage for everyone."
B. Andrew Plant is an Atlanta-based freelance writer and
is Editor at Large of A&U. He interviewed U.S. Congressman
Richard Gephardt for the November issue.
|